Northeast10.6% avg cap rateLive · 13 active listings

Finger Lakes, NY

New York wine country - lakefront and winery STR market

The Finger Lakes region is New York's premier wine country, anchored by Seneca, Cayuga, and Keuka lakes and over 130 wineries. The market draws visitors from NYC, Boston, and Toronto for wine weekends, fall foliage, and summer lakefront recreation. Lakefront properties command significant premiums and the Cornell University/Ithaca feeder market provides year-round non-seasonal demand.

10.6%
Avg Cap Rate
Net operating income / price
46%
Avg Occupancy
Annual average
$372
Avg Nightly Rate
All property types
$425K
Avg List Price
STR-viable properties

6 active listings in Finger Lakes currently rate Strong Buy

Our engine scores every for-sale property against real Airbnb comps. See which ones made the cut.

See the ranked listings

Estimated Annual Performance

Gross rental revenue
46% occ × $372/night
$62,051
Est. operating expenses
Mgmt, cleaning, supplies, insurance (~40%)
- $24,820
Est. net operating income
Before mortgage & depreciation
$37,231
At $425K avg price
Implied cap rate
8.8%

* Estimates based on market averages. Individual property performance varies. Always run a full underwriting analysis.

Why Investors Choose Finger Lakes

130+ wineries - comparable wine tourism to Napa at a fraction of the price
Seneca Lake waterfront properties earn 2-3× inland comps
Cornell University and Ithaca College drive year-round non-seasonal bookings
Accessible entry prices relative to other Northeast STR markets
Peak season: June - Oct (wine harvest: Sept-Oct)
Top property types: Lakefront Home, Farmhouse, Cottage, Single Family
Primary zip: 14891, 14456, 14871, 14837

Market averages, not guarantees. Cap rates, occupancy, and nightly rates are market-wide averages based on active STR listings and historical data. Individual property performance depends on location, amenities, management, and listing quality. Always run a full underwriting analysis before purchasing.Stats sourced from 13 active listings · last updated Jul 17, 2026

Run a live analysis in Finger Lakes

Search active MLS listings in Finger Lakes and instantly see cap rates, cash flow projections, and STR comp-backed nightly rates - all in one underwriting report.